Blu-ray Sale: Buy Two, Get One Free at Amazon.com

TMR    DVD    XBOX 360    PS3    WII    BEER    SPORTS    BABES    GEAR    FORUM
My ManRoom
Registration is free, allowing you to participate in interactive features such as reviews, contests and forums.
» Register
» Login
DVD zone
» Home & News
» Reviews
» Amazon Pre-Orders
» On Tap Releases
» Cover Art
» Member Ratings
Xbox 360 zone
» Home & News
» Games
» Reviews
» Previews
» Cover Art
» Classic Xbox
Playstation 3 zone
» Home & News
» Games
» Reviews
» Previews
» Cover Art
» Classic PS2
Wii zone
» Home & News
» Games
» Reviews
» Cover Art
Beer zone
» Home & News
» Dream Team
» Member Ratings
Sports zone
» Home & News
Babes zone
» Home & News
» Pick-O-The-Crop
Gear zone
» Reviews
» Maximum A/V
Other zones
» Gallery
» Contests
» Interviews
About TMR
» Contact
   
         
Commando Blu-ray Review
April 24, 2008

If Sainte-Chapelle’s physics-defying stained glass walls are considered Gothic church design’s greatest achievement, then Matrix’s (Arnold Schwarzenegger) impossible retrieval of his kidnapped daughter in 1985's Commando embodies the 80s indestructible action hero. You’ve never seen anything so real yet simultaneously surreal like either before, and probably never will again.

Only in Commando can a lone man facing off against *hundreds* of soldiers use shrubs as cover against automatic weapons. Frisbee-tossed circular saw blades are capable of sawing the top of a man’s head off. Jumping 100 feet from a plane’s landing gear into a swamp leaves nary a scratch or wet hair, much less any viable physical body damage. These are the non-rules defined in Commando’s world, and they energize a film that might otherwise snap.

The fuel that powers Commando’s action is Arnold Schwarzenegger performing in his prime. Without Arnold, Commando is just another B-movie laced with gratuitous violence and wooden acting, even from screen vets Dan Hedaya, Vernon Wells and Bill Duke. Arnold brings an incredible screen presence and dry humor to Commando that keeps lulls between each slaughter sequence lively. No major death is without a classic Arnold one-liner, and Rae Dawn Chong’s joke of a performance is made a joke of by Arnold’s Matrix. Even then eight-year old Alyssa Milano puts forth an Oscar-worthy performance next to Rae Dawn.

Arnold’s demeanor in Commando is a precursor to today’s Jason Statham characters: muscle-bound foreigners whose accent and charm are as deadly as their fighting abilities. Several Statham films with similar physics-defying action and indestructibility evolved from Commando, and they certainly won’t be the last.

After lengthy delays, Commando finally joins Statham staples like Crank and The Transporter on Blu-ray in a far less polished, yet serviceable package. Missing are traditional supplemental features like commentary tracks, featurettes, deleted scenes and the like. In their place are a handful of Trailers for already available catalog Fox Blu-ray titles, and D-Box Motion Code which we are unfortunately unable to test at this time, but aim to in the near future.

Visually, Commando’s 1080p MPEG-2 encoded transfer is a mixed bag depending on your viewing preferences. Heavy grain and some small film defects are visible in a number of scenes which will be frowned upon by the crowd used to a crystal clear presentation from Blu-ray Discs like Crank. Color saturation is nearly non-existent and detail wavers from one scene to next.

Older films tend to maintain this aged look intentionally, and examining Commando’s transfer from that perspective is reason to rejoice. Overall clarity, blemishes and aged presentation aside, is notably superior over the 480p DVD version. Improvements are most recognizable in close-up shots of Arnold in his attack make-up, of which there are many. Pundits of Blu-ray encoding who smirk at the use of MPEG-2 in lieu of AVC will find little ammunition to argue for the latter.

The sonic component of Commando’s assaults are still lacking despite the jump to DTS-HD Master Lossless Audio. Surrounds are virtually silent throughout, and bass doesn’t have the punch of modern films. The mixing job is still shoddy, too, with action drowning out dialogue on numerous occasions. You could argue the DTS-HD mix is an improvement over the Dolby Digital 5.1 or DTS mix, but that isn’t saying much.

One man does not make an army, not even Rambo. But in Commando, one man can surely obliterate one. Commando is a throwback to B-movie glory, only with a star-studded cast and higher production values. It shows its near quarter of a century old age with Blu-ray’s increased resolution, but still has never looked or sounded better. You don’t need anything more than a near bare-bones treatment when you can replay the over-the-top last 20 minutes over and over again in 1080p high-def.

- Dan Bradley

View all Amazon.com Blu-ray and HD DVD pre-orders

Cheers:
  • Cleaned up transfer from DVD
  • Still a classic
  • Jeers:
  • No director's cut
  • No extras save for D-Box
  • Audio still lacks punch
  • Overall:
    7.6
    Movie   8.4
    Video   7.9
    Audio   6.8
    Extras   2.0
    Replay   9.0



    latest home video news

    Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid Blu-ray Giveaway
    Fox's 'Jumper' Blu-ray to Feature D-BOX Motion Code
    'Prison Break: Season One' Blu-ray Discounted to $39.99
    Next Blu-ray Review
    Sneak Peek: Universal's 'Doomsday' Blu-ray Cover Art
    Universal Unearths 'The Mummy' Blu-ray Specs
    'Dark City' Blu-ray Disc Specs, Cover Art Revealed
    Sony Uncovers 'In the Line of Fire' Blu-ray Specs, Cover Art
    past week's news updates
    TheManRoom Home    DVD zone    Xbox 360 zone    Playstation 3 zone    Wii zone    Beer zone    Babes zone    Gear zone    Gallery    Forum
    Contests    Interviews    Terms & Privacy Policy    Contact TheManRoom
    Copyright 2003-2007, TMR Entertainment, Inc. All Rights Reserved